Morningstar built its reputation on analyst fair-value estimates and star ratings — updated on analyst schedules, locked behind a $249/year subscription. StoQuant refreshes a 149-feature ML ensemble daily, publishes the methodology, and proves it out-of-sample.
Morningstar's moat ratings and fair-value estimates come from human analysts applying discounted-cash-flow models — thoughtful work, but it updates when an analyst gets to it, covers only the names Morningstar chooses to cover, and the full reports sit behind Morningstar Investor at $249/year. StoQuant takes the quantitative route: a 149-feature ML ensemble (LightGBM + CatBoost + XGBoost with Venn-ABERS calibration) scores 3,500+ US stocks every day, a Hidden Markov Model adapts the signal to the current macro regime, and the walk-forward validation — hit rates, quintile spreads, out-of-sample AUC — is published on /proof for anyone to audit.
| Feature | StoQuant | Morningstar |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free core tier; Power plan for full API + MCP access | Free; Investor plan for research |
| Free tier limits | Full Q-Score, hidden gems, and public research pages | Limited quotes, news |
| Stocks covered | 3,500+ US stocks scored weekly | Global stocks, funds, ETFs |
| Core scoring / key differentiators | 149-feature ML ensemble with Venn-ABERS calibration | Analyst star ratings + fair value |
| ML / walk-forward proof | Published daily on /proof | No |
| AI-agent / MCP support | stoquant-mcp for Claude / AI agents | No |
| Portfolio optimization | Black-Litterman optimizer | Portfolio tools available |
| Data sources | 14 alt-data feeds (insider, social, macro, SEC, app ranks) | Analyst research, moat, ESG |
Choose Morningstar if you want long-form analyst research, economic-moat assessments, stewardship ratings, or fund and ETF analysis — decades of institutional credibility live there. Choose StoQuant if you want a daily, calibrated, multi-dimensional score across the full liquid US universe, alternative-data confirmation, value screening with margin of safety, portfolio optimization, and a published track record — without a $249/year paywall on the core signal.
Read the Q-Score methodology at /learn/q-score-methodology, check the live out-of-sample track record on /proof, and try the free intrinsic-value calculator at /intrinsic-value-calculator.
For stock ratings, yes: the Q-Score leaderboard, hidden-gem screener, and insider tracking are free, while Morningstar locks full ratings and analyst reports behind Morningstar Investor at $249/year. Morningstar still leads on fund research and long-form analyst reports.
Star ratings compare the current price to a human analyst's fair-value estimate in 1-5 buckets. Q-Score is a 0-100 calibrated probability from a 149-feature ML ensemble, refreshed daily and validated out-of-sample — finer-grained, faster, and independently auditable.
Yes, quantitatively: the Benjamin Graham intrinsic-value screener computes fair value with a 30% margin-of-safety filter, and valuation is one of the nine Q-Score dimensions. We do not employ human analysts to write per-stock DCF narratives.
Yes. /proof publishes walk-forward validation — hit rates, quintile spreads, and out-of-sample AUC — benchmarked against buy-and-hold with realistic transaction costs. The methodology is at /learn/q-score-methodology.
3,500+ US stocks, each rescored within a week. We deliberately exclude micro-caps below $250M to maintain data quality and liquidity.
Weekly Q-Score signals and insider buying activity on our highest-conviction stock picks. Email only, no account needed. See a sample digest.